By: Samantha Swayze
February 12, 2026
Sweet Deals for Valentine's Day sign in Hackettstown near Main Street. (Photo by Samantha Swayze)
As Valentine’s Day approaches, people are deciding what to eat for dinner with their loved ones. Although fancy restaurants may please some, heart-shaped pizza is a classic way to celebrate the holiday of love. Here are some places to buy your heart-shaped pizzas in Hackettstown this February.
Sonny’s II
Mike Iannaccone, Sonny's II owner, holding a heart-shaped pizza. (Source: Sonny's II website)
Sonny’s is a popular pizzeria located at 915 Country Road 517 part of a strip of stores, offering orders for pick up and local delivery.
Any pizza from their menu - all sizes and toppings - can be made heart-shaped for only $2 extra. Sonny’s will also make heart-shaped pizzas all year round!
Valentine’s Day meals can be ordered through their website, or by calling Sonny’s at 908-852-1116. Be sure to check out their social media accounts for upcoming specials, and stay tuned for a Sonny’s II Pizza review!
Taste of Italy Ristorante & Pizza
Taste of Italy's Valentine's Day Specials. (Source: Taste of Italy's website)
Taste of Italy's heart-shaped pizza with pepperoni. (Photo by Samantha Swayze on Valentine's Day in 2025)
Taste of Italy is a pizzeria and Italian restaurant located at 57 US-46, part of a strip of stores sitting across from Target. The restaurant offers orders for pick up, delivery, and dine-in.
Their large heart-shaped pizzas are $19.95 before toppings. Taste of Italy is also offering a Valentine’s Day special including a heart-shaped pizza, two cannolis, an antipasto salad, and bread for $40.
If you want to share a romantic meal with your partner, Taste of Italy offers dining in. Spend your Valentine’s Day with various menu options and their friendly server Tina!
Orders can be placed online or by calling Taste of Italy at 908-850-1303. Be sure to check their website for upcoming specials!
Davila’s
Outside view of Davila's on Main Street. (Source: Davila's Google photos)
Davila’s is located at 190 Main Street next to Stella G’s on the corner of West Moore Street and Main Street, making the restaurant within walking distance of Centenary. The restaurant offers orders for pick up, delivery, or dine-in.
They are offering large heart-shaped pizzas February 13th-15th for $2 extra, making the total $20.50 after tax.
Valentine’s Day orders can be placed online or by calling Davila’s at 908-850-9500. Be sure to check their website for upcoming specials!
Frank’s Trattoria
Frank's Trattoria Valentine's Day Specials flyer. (Source: Frank's Trattoria website)
Frank’s is located at 80 Main Street in the strip of stores near Quick Check. The restaurant offers orders for pick up, delivery, or dine-in.
Their heart-shaped pizzas are available February 12th-15th, along with their dinner specials. A personal size is $11.95, medium is $13.95, and large is $15.95.
With an order of two dinner entrees, you will receive one free dessert. Be sure to put your choice of dessert in the notes field if you are ordering your meals online!
They are also offering a dine-in only special. With an order of two dinner entrees for dine-in, you will receive one free appetizer (excluding calamari).
Orders can be placed online or by calling Frank’s at 908-852-2405. Be sure to check their website for upcoming specials!
Pasta Grill by Enzo
Pasta Grill's Galentine's Day flyer. (Source: Pasta Grill's website)
Heart-shaped pizza from Pasta Grill by Enzo. (Source: Pasta Grill by Enzo Promotional Email)
Pasta Grill is located at 1916 NJ-57 across the street from the strip of stores including Marshall’s and Kohl’s. They offer orders for pick up, delivery, and dine-in.
Their heart-shaped pizza special runs from February 13th-15th in multiple sizes. A personal size is $12, medium is $15.25, and large is $16.25.
On February 12th from 4 p.m. to 10 p.m., Pasta Grill is hosting a Galentine’s Day event with heart-shaped pizzas; their full regular, gluten free, and vegan menus; and themed cocktails and mocktails. Heart-shaped pizzas are only available for dine-in on February 12th.
On Valentine’s Day, they will be offering their heart-shaped pizzas and full regular, gluten free, and vegan menus. Dine-in specials are also available, so be sure to call and make a reservation!
Valentine’s Day orders can be placed online or by calling Pasta Grill at 908-813-8535. Be sure to check their website for upcoming specials!
Mama’s Cafe Baci
Mama's four-course Valentine dinner menu. (Source: Mama's website)
Mama’s is an Italian restaurant located at 260 Mountain Ave, directly across the street from Wendy’s. The restaurant offers orders for pick up, delivery, and dine-in.
They will be offering heart-shaped pizzas all day the 13th and 15th. On Valentine’s Day from 11 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., a heart-shaped pizza with a card and heart-shaped balloon is available for $24.
If you are looking to dine-in, Mama’s is offering a four-course dinner special for Valentine’s Day! Couples will get two salads; a sharing appetizer; two entrees; two desserts; and coffee, tea, and soft drinks for $179. Mama’s can also provide gluten free or vegan substitutions for no extra charge.
Valentine’s Day meals can be ordered online or by calling Mama’s to reserve a table at 908-852-2820. Be sure to check their website for other specials!
________
Whether you are spending your Valentine’s Day with your partner, family, or friends, Hackettstown has plenty of choices of heart-shaped pizzas and dinner specials in an assortment of price ranges. Happy Valentine’s Day!